One of the most famous of Flanders fields,
the deathbed of tens of thousands of British soldiers, is in danger of being
riven apart by a motorway.
Only an impact study stands in the way of the Flemish authorities' deciding
to route the road through the heart of the Pilkem Ridge battlefield, the site of
the opening infantry campaign in the third battle of Ypres - Wipers to the
British troops who fought and died there in July-August 1917.
If the authorities chose the candidate route the motorway will pass
perilously close to about a dozen war cemeteries maintained by the Commonwealth
war graves commission, and cut the battlefield site in two, leaving some of the
tens of thousands of British troops still listed as missing in action under a
carpet of concrete and Tarmac.
The authorities are due to decide early next year on the route of the bypass,
which is intended to reduce traffic through several villages.
The road, connecting the area to the coast, should open in 2004 or 2005.
Piet Chielens, of the In Flanders Fields Museum in Ypres - Ieper in Flemish -
said that to build the road there would be a historical mistake of epic
proportions. It should be placed in a historically less significant area.
"Building over Pilkem Ridge is like building over the battlefield at Waterloo
- it's as important for European history," he told the Guardian yesterday.
"From an educational and historical point of view, if you build a road
straight through this battlefield you will completely and utterly destroy the
traces of how the offensive went, and if you want to follow in the footsteps of
the battle in future you just won't be able to do so.
"This was the biggest thing that ever happened in the war at Ieper, and the
battlefield has been left almost untouched for the last 84 years."
More than 30,000 British soldiers died in the three days of Pilkem Ridge. By
November, when Third Ypres ended, the British had managed to advance only five
miles, to the obliterated village of Passchendaele. Historians reckon that more
than 300,000 British soldiers died, along with 200,000 Germans.
"Bar the Somme, this was the British army's worst catastrophe," Mr Chielens
said .
The war graves commission says it is also concerned about the roadbuilding
plan, but stresses that its remit is preserving war graves not battlefields.
And, the commission says, it is not uncommon in France and Belgium for the
authorities to build bypasses and main roads right beside cemeteries. Of greater
concern is the fact that almost 100,000 British bodies lie concealed in the
area's rich soil.
"We all know what contractors are like," a commission spokesman, Barry
Murphy, said.
"If you have a lot of road works and they are up against a deadline the last
thing they're going to do is call the police, stop work and let the
archaeologists on site."
The cause has been taken up by a campaigning Belgian green senator, Michiel
Maertens, who wants the road located elsewhere. "This plan is not on : we have
to do something," he said.
"This area is virginal: it has remained untouched and the farms and roads are
just as they were in 1917. It must stay like this."
A spokesman for the Flemish authorities confirmed yesterday that the Pilkem
Ridge site was a candidate for the new motorway but stressed that a final
decision would only be taken after a proper impact study.
There was a glimmer of hope last night, however, when sources close to the
Flanders environment minister said he was willing to consider listing the
battlefield as a world heritage site. But a thorough investigation into the
area's historical value is needed before that can be done.
Meanwhile British officials are still checking whether plans for a third
Paris airport will involve relocating first world war cemeteries.