Aftermath - when the boys came home

Sunday 7 September 2008

Recent Additions
   & Updates
Search the site


Site Information
Resources

 

News clips

from Daily Mirror  Thursday  31 August  2000

A Grave InsultWar Graves Scandal: We can't look after the dead if they won't pay us a living

from HARRY ARNOLD in Ypres
and LUCY ROCK

IN Flanders' fields yesterday, British workers were preparing to fight for their jobs.

War Graves scandalIt is here, where the flower of the nation's youth died in battle, that dedicated gardeners tend the roses and memorials that mark their sacrifice.

Now Whitehall cutbacks threaten to slash their annual pay by as much as pounds 6,000, saving the Government only a few hundred thousand pounds a year.

One senior gardener who cares for British war graves at Ypres in Belgium said: "What is about to happen is a disgrace to the memory of the men who died.

"I have three children and I am about to lose around £450 a month from my salary. It will be impossible for me to survive and I shall have to return to Britain."

Another gardener explained: "Our task is to train local staff to tend the graves to the highest possible standard. When we go the work will continue but we believe the standards will drop.

"The local gardeners are good workers. But to them it is just a job. They have no understanding of the sensitivity involved in this work. I am not saying that the graves will fall into rack and ruin, but they will not be the superb monuments they are today.

"Do the British people want the very best for the men who died for their freedom? Or do they want second best?"

The 77 British gardeners working for the Commonwealth War Graves Commission earn a basic wage of between £10,500 and £13,500 a year plus an allowance for living abroad. It is the cutback on their overseas top-up, due in the autumn, which will cost them thousands.

The commission is responsible for cemeteries in 150 countries including France, Belgium, Holland, Germany and India - and in the Far East and Africa.

Most of the gardeners are based in northern France where thousands of visitors flock each year, many looking for the plaques of relatives killed in action. Visitors are struck by the row upon row of dazzling white headstones and neat borders of shrubs and roses.

Chris Kaufman, of the TGWU union which represents many of the gardeners, said: "Their dedication and pride in their work maintains these graves and cemeteries impeccably.

"They are the friendly British face for thousands of emotional pilgrimages by the modern generation tracking down fathers, grandfathers and great grandfathers to their last resting place. We are proud of their work and of the tremendous role played by the commission.

"But this has hit them very hard. It will affect the poorest paid and those with children the hardest. The TGWU will battle for justice on this issue, if needs be taking it to the highest levels of government."

Andrew MacKinlay, Labour MP for Thurrock in Essex, plans to challenge the cuts in the Commons. He said: "The Commonwealth and War Graves Commission does have a limited budget and that should be revised. The cemeteries are precious to all of us, including ex-servicemen and the widows and relatives of soldiers who died fighting for our country.

"The local staff are caring and professional, but the British staff have the language skills and that extra bit of interest which is so important for visitors. I don't think the public want to see the slightest reduction in standards in the cemeteries."

One gardener who looks after scores of cemeteries in northern France, said: "I am looking at losing about pounds 6,000 off my yearly income. It's extremely worrying. I've got children of school age and this is going to make things very difficult.

"Our basic wage is very low and we relied on the overseas allowance to give us a living wage. We will have to tighten our belts and hope for the best."

The gardener added: "It is difficult for our wives to work because we are moved from country to country every so often. I love working for the commission and am really proud of the work I do. But I feel let down."

Another gardener, who is losing around £4,000 a year, said: "We often chat to visitors and help them find the headstones of their relatives and tell them about the cemeteries or the battles where they were killed. But we are dwindling in numbers and these cuts in allowances would make it more difficult for family people to come and work here anyway.

"We look after up to 45 cemeteries each, depending on their size, and supervise a team of local staff to help us. We are trained horticulturists who teach the locals how to dig and plant, but if we went I don't think the standards would be the same."

Ironically, the Europe-based directors who have control of the war graves have recently had pay rises.

A gardener at Ypres pointed out: "War graves commissioners come every year with VIP visitors and they always stay in the best hotels. Just a short while ago a party of them visited a war cemetery in Berlin and they all stayed in the Berlin Hilton. I didn't take this job for the money, but the waste at the top does make me angry."

Peter Francis, spokesman for the Commonwealth War Graves Commission, said: "The allowances have been recalculated.

"There has also been a reduction in the number of UK staff serving overseas. We are employing far more local staff than in the past.

"Like any organisation we have to account for our budget and make sure we spend that in the best possible way to achieve the best standards we can."

 

Back to News Clips Contents

Member of the History Channel
visit aftermath books
In association with Amazon